
By Michael Mattingly, Lead Golf Columnist
Spring 1970, Monmouth College
Inside a bedroom in a fraternity house at Monmouth College, a college student is lying on the floor between two speakers.
Led Zeppelin II is turning on a record player.
The album had been released a few months earlier. By now, the vinyl has become familiar. The needle finds its groove. Jimmy Page’s guitar comes alive through the speakers, filling the room with that strange, enormous sound that seemed to belong to somewhere else entirely.
At the end of “What Is and What Should Never Be,” the guitar begins to move.
Left speaker.
Right speaker.
Left.
Right.
A conversation between two guitars bouncing across the room.
Another student, a woman, knocks on the door and walks into the room. She sees him lying there between the speakers.

“Let the song finish,” she says.
So she waits; The song finishes.
And somehow, fifty-six years later, it still hasn’t.
Because we own that record.
Not a digital copy. Not a playlist. Not some remastered version streaming through a phone.
The actual record.
The same Led Zeppelin II that was spinning on that turntable in 1970.
Every once in a while, in the late summer of 2026, that record finds its way onto our turntable. The needle drops. The crackle comes first. Then the guitar.
And when “What Is and What Should Never Be” reaches that strange conversation at the end, my mother-in-law isn’t really sitting in our backyard anymore.
She’s back in that fraternity house.
She’s young again.
The room is dark.
The speakers are loud.
And somebody has just said, “Let the song finish.”
Maybe that’s what we are really doing out there on a golf course.
We think we’re playing a round.
But we’re also leaving little recordings of ourselves behind.
A particular shot.
A particular person.
A particular September afternoon.
A breeze moving through the trees.
The sound of a golf ball catching the center of the clubface.
Someone laughing beside the cart.
A putt that somehow found the bottom of the cup.
We don’t know which moments are going to stay with us.
We don’t know which ordinary afternoon will eventually become one of the songs we hear later.
That’s the funny thing about memory.
It doesn’t always preserve the moments we think are important.
Sometimes it keeps the ones we barely noticed.
A song playing in a fraternity bedroom.
A woman standing in a doorway.
A golf ball sitting beside a cup.
A particular quality of September light.
And then, fifty years later, something happens.
The song starts.
The leaves move.
The air changes.
And suddenly the needle drops again.
We’re there.
Not remembering it.
There.
Maybe that’s why I love fall golf.
There is something about the first real coolness in the air that makes a golf course feel like a place where the past and present can occupy the same patch of ground.
Summer is loud. Summer demands something from you. The heat, the humidity, the long days, the golf course baked hard beneath your feet.
Fall is different.
The light gets lower. The grass softens. The greens begin to hold a little more. There is a breeze that doesn’t feel like an adversary anymore. Leaves begin collecting along the edges of the fairways, and suddenly a golf course looks less like a piece of property and more like a memory.
Maybe that’s when the recordings start playing.
I have one from the fall of 1999.
I had been taking lessons from a local pro named Dan Polites. The course where we played was Westhaven, a little par-three course that is gone now, swallowed up by time and whatever came after it.
I remember the course being narrow and lined with trees.
I remember being young enough to think I was going to figure this game out.
And I remember one particular shot.
The ball came off the club and started toward the hole.
It finished less than a foot from the cup.
Eight inches, maybe.
I have told the story enough times that I can still see it.
The ball rolled toward the hole.
And I swear it rolled over the cup.
It didn’t go in.
Of course it didn’t.
That’s not how I remember it.
I remember what it almost was.
And that may be the most golf thing of all.
Because for most golfers, there are two versions of almost every round.
There is what happened.
And there is what should have happened.
The drive that should have found the fairway.
The approach that should have stopped beside the flag.
The putt that broke exactly the way we read it—except it didn’t.
The birdie that lived for a second before becoming par.
The round that could have been 78.
The round that somehow became 84.
We carry these things around with us.
Not because we’re obsessed with failure, but because golf leaves the door open just enough for imagination to walk through.
What if?
What if the putt had dropped?
What if the wind had held?
What if I had taken one less club?
What if I had trusted the swing?
What if?
And maybe that’s why that old Zeppelin song fits golf better than I ever realized.
For most golfers, What Is and What Should Never Be eventually becomes something slightly different.
What was and what should have been.
Because golf is an endless conversation between those two things.
What happened.
And what we remember happening.
The shot we actually hit.
And the shot that lives forever in our heads.
The ball that stopped eight inches from the hole.
And the ball that, in the private version of the story, rolled right over the cup.
Maybe the distinction doesn’t matter.
Maybe that’s the point.
Because the older I get, the less interested I am in correcting the memory.
I don’t need to know whether that ball actually caught the lip, skipped over the hole, or simply came to rest eight inches away.
I was there.
I remember the shot.
And somewhere in the back of my mind, that little piece of fall golf is still spinning.
Like a record.
Waiting for the needle to find it again.
And that’s what I like about this time of year.
Fall doesn’t feel like an ending to me.
It feels like a return.
Baseball is winding down. Football is beginning. The sports calendar changes its rhythm. The mornings get cooler. The light gets different.
And underneath all of it is the golf course, waiting for us.
Waiting for the temperature to drop.
Waiting for the leaves to change.
Waiting for somebody to hit one more good shot before the year gets away from us.
You don’t get to keep the round. Nobody does.
The scorecard goes in a drawer. The course changes. The people get older.
What you get to keep are the recordings.
And you never know which ones will become important.
It might be the birdie.
It might be the terrible shot that somehow made everybody laugh.
It might be the round where you played your best golf of the year.
Or it might be the afternoon when you played like hell but somebody you loved was sitting beside you in the cart.
Years later, the details will blur.
The scorecard won’t matter.
The exact number of putts won’t matter.
But something will remain.
A sound.
A smell.
A face.
A particular light.
A golf ball sitting beside a cup.
A song coming through two speakers.
And suddenly, without warning, you’re back there.
The needle drops.
The guitar begins to move from one speaker to the other.
Left.
Right.
Left.
Right.
And somewhere, in a little fraternity bedroom in 1970, a young woman is standing in a doorway saying, “Let the song finish.”
So you do.
You let the song finish.
You let the memory play.
And then you go outside.
Because there’s a golf course waiting.
And somewhere out there, in the cool September air, is another recording you haven’t made yet. Let the song finish.
Enjoy Your Sunday – MWM

